Real Fiction and Fake Fiction–both are Fiction

I was brought up on a strict diet of Star Trek, Star Wars and basically any scifi that my parents could get their hands on back in the 90s in Tokyo. We had friends in the USA tape the latest TV programs including Babylon 5, send then in the mail and then binge watch them, about 4 episodes a night. I have been binge watching scifi before it was even an option for the rest of the world. So it was of no surprise that the material I wanted to read the most was scifi. I tried the American Girl series, remember those? But I hated them. I would sit there and turn the page every five minutes or so rather than actually read them. Then I met Bruce Coville, and Aliens Ate My Homework and caught the reading bug.

In my naivete, I thought this was normal. I’d never met anyone who didn’t love scifi. At university I found out the hard way, and got strangely made fun of for this love. Someone told me that they only read real literature, or rather realistic fiction. What is interesting to them is real life. They don’t need to pretend. Human nature is the biggest mystery. I was surprised, I felt a bit of shame, and then I got over it and kept on reading what I liked.

But I disagree with his premise. I have read widely now, and I do like ‘real life’ fiction, but it will never be scifi. Less imagination, and it is only with scifi that you can test human nature to the ultimate limits–see what those characters are actually made of. I can go through my own life experiences real life, I want my reading to be more than that. Also, I want to believe in more. I want to believe in the impossible. There is a sort of optimism in scifi even when it turns to horror from humans experimenting where they shouldn’t. We are curious. We push boundaries! Its exciting.

So I guess I’m wondering, is there a stigma against reading scifi? Or did I just meet a few jerks back in university (very possible)? Is there a stigma against writing scifi? I was excited to see that locally here in New Zealand this one guy has just set up his own scifi exclusive publishing house. It is beyond cool.


6 thoughts on “Real Fiction and Fake Fiction–both are Fiction

    • Any limitations on reading seems a bit close minded–that being said the book I’m currently reading is horror (in an attempt to get out of my compartment), and I am realizing that I just can’t quite stomach it. Too much eating of people alive…


  1. I think there is a stigma attached to sci-fi. The stigma is that only awkward, nerdy people are interested in sci-fi. However, I feel like the stigma is starting to fade and that sci-fi is more widely accepted. I don’t know why this stigma developed, but it seems like people who judge it to be something “nerdy” and make fun of others might not have given it much of a chance. I don’t know about writing sci-fi, but it seems like it’s only recently become a more popular genre.


    • I’m not sure how it got that stigma. Also that mainly it is a ‘guy’ genre. Very excited to see the ‘nerdy’ aspect fading away, and I can’t help but think the whole ‘geek chic’ phenomena helped.


  2. Some of the best novels I’ve read are sci-fi, including (and not limited to) Orson Scott Card’s ‘Ender’s Game’, Frank Herbert’s ‘Dune’, Neal Stephenson’s ‘Snow Crash’, all extremely entertaining and simultaneously highly sophisticated. Next time you meet someone who disses sci-fi, remind them of ‘Frankenstein’ ‘Brave New World’ ‘Nineteen Eighty-Four’—it’d be difficult for anyone to deny those as ‘real literature’. Also, check out a documentary film called ‘Jodorowsky’s Dune’! It’s audaciously pro-art and an enthralling presentation of creative freedom.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s